She had been the world's most famous photographer, but by the time of
her death from Parkinson's Disease, MARGARET BOURKE-WHITE was isolated
from all but a few colleagues. Here, the author of a new Bourke-White
collection recalls working with her in those final days, and how he came
to know her as the consummate journalist.
By Sean Callahan
"Can you go up to Connecticut and meet with Bourke-White and find out
what the hell is going on," said Dick Pollard when I walked into his
office at Life. This was actually an order, not a question, since he was
the picture editor of the magazine and I a newly minted junior editor.
It was 1970 and Life was still the world's preeminent showcase for
photojournalism. Pollard's title put him near the top of the masthead,
but he had a special clout because
he had been with the magazine since
its beginnings in the late '30s. He had worked with all the great Life
photographers, carrying their cameras, taking down the picture captions,
comforting their spouses and lovers (and never confusing the two).
On this day, Pollard overlaid his authority with a theatrical
crankiness. He said he'd been getting calls from gallery owners who
wanted to put up exhibitions of Margaret Bourke-White's photographs, but
he hadn't been able to communicate on the phone with her about the
projects. "With my bad ear and her Parkinsonism--even if I can get her
on the phone, I can't understand her," he said.
His bluster was a cover for a concern for an old colleague.
Bourke-White was more than just a member of the Life family; she was a
founding mother--the photographer who shot the magazine's first cover
(November 23, 1936). Although she hadn't taken a picture for the magazine since 1957, her
name remained on the masthead until 1969.
Ft. Peck Dam construction,
Life's first cover.
Bourke-White was more than just an in-house link to a glamorous
past, however. She was a world-famous symbol of swashbuckling
photojournalism, perhaps more widely known and celebrated than any
photographer has ever been. Becoming whom she did in a male dominated
world made her achievements only more legendary.
But by the late 1960s the celebration of the '30s, '40s, and '50s
had been replaced by sickness and isolation. With no husband or children
of her own, she relied on her Life family--now in the person of Dick
Pollard--to help her deal with the outside world. As the new kid in the
photo department, I was being dispatched on an errand by the adults of
the household.
Margaret Bourke-White felt the first effects of Parkinson's disease
while in Korea in 1952.
The woman who had been torpedoed in the Mediterranean, strafed by the
Luftwaffe, stranded on a Arctic island, bombarded in Moscow, and pulled
out of the Chesapeake when her chopper crashed, was known to the Life
staff as "Maggie the Indestructible." But fierce pride and a ferocious
work ethic compelled her to keep her self-described "mysterious malady"
a secret from her colleagues for years.
She had just turned 50 when she had to slow her career to fight off
encroaching paralysis, first with physical therapy and then, in 1959
and again in 1961, with brain surgery.
The operations stilled her
tremors but caused her speech to become impaired. She went about writing her memoirs (an autobiography,
Portrait of Myself, was published in 1963 and became a best seller) but
in the following years she grew increasingly infirm and gradually
withdrew from the world.
Two failed marriages and numerous passionate (and very public) love
affairs had fallen victim to Bourke-White's professional life. The
invalided Peggy White was alone and had few friends. She expressed no
remorse at this. Her indomitable will was focused on overcoming her
affliction and, when that became less likely, staving it off.
There were money problems, however. A pension plan set up in the
'50s, though generous for that time, no longer adequately covered her
escalating health care costs. Her precarious financial situation was
compounded by personal generosity and less-than-responsible attendant
care. With the help of a neighbor friend, changes were made in her
nursing care. My task was to find a way to help her capitalize on her
photographic accomplishments; these had long been neglected, especially
by the photographer herself.
The woman I met in Darien, Connecticut--her home lay on a rocky hill at
the end of a secluded road--walked haltingly with the aid of a personal
attendant. By her cheerful expression she was happy to receive a
visitor; but she spoke in a painfully slow, raspy whisper.
This figure,
who had been a popular and well-paid personality on the lecture circuit,
a commentator on CBS Radio during the war, an intimate of writers (she
was married to Erskine Caldwell for a while) and editors and politicians and who could hold her own in their lively debates, now struggled mightily to string a few
words together.
With husband Erskine Caldwell
covering the Russian front, 1940.
My first reaction was embarrassment, but it was misplaced. Nothing
stopped her from making the effort to communicate, and she greeted me
with a warmth and enthusiasm that actually seemed inappropriate for a
first meeting--that is, until I realized that we had this "family"
connection.
Much of the conversation that day was small talk about the magazine.
"Dick sends his regards; he says he's turning deaf but conveniently so
when photographers petition him about how the editors used all the wrong
pictures again. Yes, Eisie still comes into the office every day and
still takes the milk carton home with him after lunch, forcing the rest
of the photo staff to drink their afternoon coffee black." And so on.
Her eyes soared in delight as I spun out the stories.
One of the strange side effects of her Parkinsonism was that her
skin was smooth and luminous. Except when she smiled, there was not line
in her face, and she was then 66. But the most compelling feature was
her blue-grey eyes, bright and clear and penetratingly sharp. They
seemed to follow my words as if they were being projected as subtitles.
I soon realized that her eyes were not effected by the paralysis, and,
whether consciously or not, this was how she animated her side of a
conversation. Her eyes literally danced, and she used them to replace
gesture, tone, and posture.
Tea was served, a tour of the house taken--the living room was wall
papered in one huge, floor-to-ceiling, perfectly-stitched-together
black-and-white photograph of an evergreen forest that she had shot in
Czechoslovakia in 1938--and mementos of her remarkable career discussed.
By the time it was dark we agreed that
she should give some pictures to the Lee Witkin Gallery, which wanted to
mount a show; as factotum from the magazine, I would help her do it. As
it turned out, this was just the first of many extraordinary Saturday
afternoons I spent at the house over the next 18 months, revisiting the
history of magazine photojournalism through the eyes of one of its
foremost practitioners with her at my side to guide me through it.

Moravian forest
scene, 1938.
After another visit it was clear to me that she had been the
consummate photojournalist. She had lived for the story, and as soon as
she told it in pictures, and later in books (she wrote or illustrated
ten books, many of which were deeper and more personal explorations of
subjects that had been photo essays in Life) she moved on to the next
assignment.
Throughout her career she had little time for making fine prints or
exhibiting them. Although she saw herself as a photographic artist of
the stature of Stieglitz (whom in her 20s she had hoped to emulate), she had no time for the artifice of the art world. There just
weren't many matted and signed vintage prints in Darien from which to
make a gallery exhibition. There were, however, thousands of curling and
faded work prints with crop marks and tape and log numbers--the residue
of a working photographer.
When I made my report to Pollard it was decided that it was in both
Bourke-White's and the magazine's interest to promote her work to the
small but growing audience of photography enthusiasts--an audience that
Lee Witkin had astutely identified. In my spare time I'd pull together
an archive of saleable vintage prints that would be augmented by modern
prints in a limited edition; these would be made under the supervision
of George Karas, who now ran the Life Photo Lab but who, as a young man,
had been Bourke-White's printer there.
A book of her photographs was
needed--she never had published a real monograph--to serve as a catalog
for a generation that had grown up not having seen her work.
Interestingly, the publisher of that 1971 book, The Photographs of
Margaret Bourke-White, The New York Graphic Society, was later reconstituted as Bulfinch Press, which is
bringing out a new collection titled Margaret Bourke-White,
Photographer.
This book, which I wrote the text for, contains many
pictures not seen in the earlier one; indeed, some have never been
published before. It should introduce Bourke-White to a new generation.
Over the succeeding months of working with Bourke-White-- selecting
vintage prints, preparing a portfolio that she approved and made futile
attempts at signing, and collecting the details for the first
mongraph--my ear became more attuned to her speech. We developed a
verbal shorthand that often had me finishing her sentences in a number
of versions until she signaled that I had finally got it right. And then
we would both laugh at the verbal gymnastics that I had gone through.
Maggie was indestructible of spirit.
And body too. On several occasions I would get so immersed in the
prints and negatives that I didn't notice that she had padded off to get
something to show me-- until I heard a frightening crash. And there she
would be, helpless on the floor, with a big smile on her face.
In time, it became easy to see through the paralysis and years to
the women who had captivated both her subjects and colleagues--male,
especially. Though encased in a body that was slowly becoming a cast, the
photographer's insatiable quest for perfection--"just one more,
please"--was still there. Once, we were looking at the original negative
(on deteriorating acetate film stock!) of a Russian ballerina made in
1931. It was what her biographer and photo critic Vicki Goldberg has
called the "posed candid," a kind of carefully arranged informal
portrait that Bourke-White invented.
She was disturbed by something she
seemed to notice in the image for the first time, although perhaps 40
years had passed since she held it in her hands. There was a shadow that
shouldn't be there. And she proceeded to tell me how the picture could
have been improved.
Semionova, Premiere Ballerina, 1931.
To many who got in the way of a Bourke-White photograph--and that
included not just bureaucrats and functionaries but professional
colleagues like assistants, reporters, and other photographers--she was
regarded as imperious, calculating, and insensitive. But I was startled
one day, after going through the pictures she made of Buchenwald and the
aftermath of Nazi Germany, which she published in her book Dear
Fatherland, Rest Quietly 25 years earlier, when she began to weep.
Beginning in the late 1920s, Bourke-White's imagery--full of drama,
romance, echoing pattern, and daring perspective--made her an innovative
and acclaimed photographer. But that was not enough to make her a
photojournalist. She also had the unerring instinct of a journalist, an
instinct that led her to be the first Western photographer to document
Soviet industry after the revolution, and to create a travelog of
Czechoslovakia and other Balkan states just before Hitler moved in to
ignite World War II, and to get herself stationed in Moscow just before
Germany bombed its former ally. She had, in addition to the mastery of the medium and the eye of
an artist, the daring, cunning, and intuition to be where news would be
happening. Once there, she could rise to the occasion. In this regard
she is the spiritual mother to photojournalists like Harry Benson, James
Nachtwey, and Susan Meisalas.
When I last saw Bourke-White, in the summer of 1971, it was after
she had taken one of those crashing falls, only this time her ribs
destructed. She was bedridden in the hospital and unable to continue her
physical therapy. In her weakened state, the paralysis advanced; there
was now not even a faint whisper. I was on my way to Boston to deliver
another exhibition to a gallery, and I pulled out some of the prints and
try to talk with her. But this time she could only move her eyes, so we
abbreviated our shorthand to one blink for "yes" and two blinks for
"no."
I started my patter about what was happening at the magazine,
reverted to my visuals--"what was it like shooting these snow geese from
a helicopter?"--before I ran out of self-restraint. We had successfully
bantered with her blinks taking me down the conversational path she
wanted to traverse, but when my eyes started to fill with tears, she
graciously let me know that she was tired and that it was time for me to
go.
Two days later she died, but, fittingly for the heroic,
larger-than-Life Margaret Bourke-White, the eyes were the last to go.